READER MESSAGES PAGE

<<PREVIOUS | EWM HOME PAGE

READER MESSAGES LATE APRIL 1999

From: "Rich Cook" rac@fwi.com
To: "Aidan O'Rourke" aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: A couple of photos
Date: Fri, 15 Jan 1999 18:30:01 -0500

Aidan, I finally got my photo's. "Snow" (right) is looking out of my driveway down the street, it is hard to see the amount of snow on the ground, at this point the snowfall had been around 18" with drifting up to several feet. "play snow" (inset) shows my son standing on the driveway with the drifted/shoveled snow behind him. He is 42" tall, so this gives a little idea of what we had. Other areas North of Ft Wayne had more snow and worse conditions overall. Forecast for the weekend.........up to 48F on Sunday.....get out the sun tan oil and swimming trunks!!! Will keep you posted. Rich Cook

Wish we could have some of that over here!
Envelope-to: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Date: Tue, 12 Jan 1999 16:57:47 -0500
Subject: Hi Aidan
From: "David Boardman" david.boardman@accglobal.net
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com

Just want to say that I am continually gobsmacked at the quality of your photographs. As you know I have been following your site for a long time and checking out my home town through your ears and eyes has been a regular weekly stop for me. It is the interesting choice of photographic subjects and the sheer excellence of the photography that blows me away every week. You really have a feel for the city that is so much a part of the lives of expats around the world. Have you ever considered putting them into a coffee table book. You could do one a year. A year in the life of our city. Put me down for one.

Can you bring me up to date with the status of some of my favourite old buildings. What's happening at the Victoria Baths these days. I know that's not far from your home. Has anything happened to the Central Fire Station? I know they were talking of redeveloping it. I hope it is still intact. The Longsight Police Station and the Daisy Mill used to sit across Stockport road from each other. I know there is a new Longsight Police Station. Does this mean the old one will be demolished? In relation to the picture of the Malmaison Hotel. Was the Doll's Hospital in the old section of that building or was it further along and gone now?

All the best from frigid Ontario. We have waist deep snow now and tonight they expect the low temperature to reach -30C. Makes you glad you live on the Costa del Irwell right!

David

When the weather was good just over a week ago, I didn't hear people saying how wonderful it was - they just complained about the cold. People don't appreciate how lucky they are to live here!

Now to answer your questions - I am planning a coffee table book, but it will be quite some time yet before it comes out. In the meantime, you can run a slide show of 20 stunning full-screen size colour photos on your desktop with my Eyewitness in Manchester City Centre Walking Tour screensaver, available shortly in the Manchester Online shop for only £4.99 (technical side done by Manchester Online's chief designer Simon). Several pictures are "previously unreleased" and the others I have specially rescanned and enhanced to look their best, so please go the Manchester Online shop later this week!

The Central Fire Station - picture above right, is in my opinion one of the most magnificent buildings in Manchester. But it is still mostly empty and awaiting a new use. Plans to convert it into a hotel came to nothing. The Victoria Baths (pictures coming soon) on Hathersage Road have lain empty since Manchester City Council closed them in 1992 - the building was open on the Heritage Open days last September - the interior is superb - some parts look almost new, but the main users of the building these days are pigeons, whose droppings cover the floors and empty pool bottoms. The old Longsight Police Station was demolished last year after the new one was opened (see picture right) - I didn't get a photo of the old building unfortunately. You can see the Daisy Mill along Stockport Rd to the right. As for the Doll's Hospital, I'm not sure, leave that one with me! Oh, and thanks for the words of praise, they mean a lot!


From: "Vincent Marsden" vmarsden@ladenburg.com
Date: Mon, 11 Jan 1999 13:52:34 -0500

I enjoyed the e-mail from John Hoolachan last week. I went to De La Salle College in Salford, having been to St. Lukes RC at Irlams O'th Height (my dad was the headmaster there and taught his entire career there - he is called Terence Marsden). John has had a more varied travel life than me. I came over here on a student exchange program (BUNAC) at the end of university and enjoyed and stayed.

I wanted to mention that you can now get a new BBC channel in the USA called BBC America. As far as I know it is only currently available on DishTV (www.dishnetwork.com) and while the programming is somewhat limited it is nonetheless terrific for expats. We just had it installed last week and have been watching it all of the time. Unfortunately, since it only carries BBC programs we don't get Coronation Street, but my wife is a big EastEnders fan so she gets to keep up-to-date.

I can't wait to go online on a Tuesday to see your weekly update, and from the looks of your mailbag, the word is getting around. I have a cousin who recently moved to Florida so I have sent him the address for Manchester Online and told him to be certain to check out EWM.

Happy and healthy New Year
Vince Marsden

 

Thank you very much indeed for the message. The BBC is good - I remember the feeling of joy and relief when we first tuned in to BBC World in Saudi Arabia in 1992 - but it's still not as good as domestic BBC1 and 2, plus the other channels. British TV is the best in the world.

From: Anniean@aol.com


 

Date: Fri, 8 Jan 1999 23:53:06 EST
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Greetings from Chicago
Greetings!

I'm not actually in Chicago but about 30 miles west. We have had quite a bit of snow over the past week. It started on January 2 very early in the morning. by the time I woke up at about 8:00am we already had 2-3 inches. It continued for most of the day. The city got about 24 inches with the strong winds there were drifts that covered cars. We got another 1-2 inches on Tuesday/Wednesday and a few more inches today. In between the snow we are having bitter cold temps as low as 20(f) below. We are expected to get more snow in the upcoming week.

Until Christmas we were expecting unusually warm weather with temps up to 70 (f) I guess we're paying for it now! We have not have this much snow in about 10 years and hopefully we won't have it again for another 10 years!...lol oh well that's life in the Midwest. If anyone is thinking of visiting Chicago I would definatly suggest the warmer months.

I love your page and try to visit often. Stay warm!

Annie Nickels
Woodridge, Illinois

Today (Saturday 9 Jan) was gloriously sunny and cold - my favourite weather. No snow yet!


From: "F. Hadland" frankh@unix.infoserve.net
To: "Aidan O'Rourke" aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Re: St Annes Square

My mother used to work at Marshall and Snelgroves in the 30's, 40',50's She is long dead now. I believe that M & S went bankrupt?, can you confirm? Just wondering. I cannot relate your picture to the square as I remember it. I left M/c in 1952.

Regards Frank Hadland, Vancouver, Canada.

They've gone, as far as I know, though the name is familiar. The main M&S in Manchester nowadays is Marks and Spencer. Which picture were you referring to?


Greetings:
The photo I referred to was #659 (upper right) . I also noted photo #650 (right) . I lived in Burnage, (After being blitzed from Salford) very close to Burnage High school, from 1941 to 1952. One of the movie houses that I am my "gang" visited in that period was the Capital cinema. We also paid visits to an "Odeon" cinema, later named "The Lido" on Kingsway in Burnage. I believe that that was converted to a bowling alley. I think that my mother told this to me in her letters.

Regards Frank Hadland.

P.S. I make it a point to visit your site each week. You are really doing an excellent job in promoting Manchester, and also bringing back very dim memories.

The Capitol Cinema was used as a TV studio, then as a theatre. It's currently being demolished to make way for upmarket apartments. As for the Lido, Kingsway, this is now, I think, a branch of Kwik Save. Some Kingsway pictures coming soon. And thanks for your kind words!


Date: Fri, 08 Jan 1999 09:19:49 -0500
From: susan healey-mills ride4311@ride.ri.net
Reply-To: ride4311@ride.ri.net
Organization: barrington school department
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com, ride4311@ride.ri.net
Subject: "Manchester People"
Aidan:
As an ex Mancunian now residing in the United States, I particularly enjoy the information on your Web Pages - nice for me to be able to keep "in touch" from 3,000 miles away!
I would like to know whether you would kindly give me any information about the following "Manchester People", and their careers:

1 PETER DONAHOE (DONAHUE-?-) A classical pianist who has performed on many occasions for the BBC (radio) and who, as a child, was raised in Chorlton. I would like to know about his music career and
whether he still lives in England.

2 PAUL ARTHURS ("Oasis" guitarist). My young daughter is a fan of the Band and has compiled quite an extensive "scrapbook" about their music. To complete this, to date, she would just like to know the specific area
of Manchester (town / village name, please) where Paul now resides. (Also, whether he still supports Manchester United!!). Many thanks, Aidan for your assistance in the above - I do hope you will be able to answer, for us, the items mentioned. Thank You.
Kind regards.........Susan. (R.I., U.S.A.) January 7th, 1999
(email: RIDE4311@RIDE.RI.NET)

Peter Donohue, the distinguished concert pianist, was born 18th of June 1953. He went to Chorlton Park Primary School, Chethams College, Leeds University, the Royal Manchester College of Music, the RNCM, and the Paris Conservatoire. His debut was at Manchester Free Trade Hall (right) in 1966, and he went on to perform all over the world. Among many accolades, he won the Gramphone Concerto Record of the Year Award in 1988. I'm not sure whether he lives in England, though his agents are in London. I can provide their address if you like.

As for Paul Arthurs, I've no idea at the moment where he lives, but I will consult some of my contacts, and get back to you on that.

By the way, I don't have an encyclopedic knowledge of all things Mancunian - the above info is taken from the fascinating "Who's Who in Greater Manchester" published by Manchester Literary and Philosophical Publications Ltd, 1996 edition - they were selling them recently for £1.50 in the Stationery Office on Albert Square!


From: "Rich Cook" rac@fwi.com
To: "Aidan O'Rourke" aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Let it Snow!!!
Date: Wed, 6 Jan 1999 23:48:05 -0500

Hi Aidan, I don't have any photos to offer..........I could have some early next week. I am 3 hours from Chicago.....they received around 18 inches, plus high winds causing drifting. In Ft Wayne we had about 8 inches over the weekend and another 4 today, also had high winds causing drifting....I have about 3 feet in some places around my house. The temperature was down to -16 Fahrenheit here Monday night, the wind chill made it feel like -40. We are supposed to get more snow plus an ice storm before the start of next week.....Florida sounds more inviting each day!!!! Chicago typically gets more snow than we do here due to the lake effect. I will get some pics and send to you ASAP. Rich Cook

It's going to get cold this weekend - it might even dip below freezing point! We're all looking forward to the photos!

 


From: "Douglas Minke" dgminke@sentex.net
Subject: Where is Karlene
Date: Thu, 7 Jan 1999 13:54:48 -0500

Dear Aidan, I am trying to get in touch with Karlene Osborne. I do not know her married name.

She used to live in Reddish. We worked together in 1959 in Selsey at a caravan camp which belonged to a John Barnes. I would love to hear from her. My married name is Moira Minke and I live in Canada. Thank you.

My maiden name is Connor. my email address is dgminke@sentex.net

Thanks for the message. You may have more success in finding your friend if you use the "In Touch" section of Manchester Online. Hope you find her. Does anyone out there know Karlene Osborne????


Date: Thu, 07 Jan 1999 01:57:41 +0000
From: Martin Bryant ics7mb@leeds.ac.uk
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Your photographs.
Wow! That's all I can say really after seeing your vast number of photos of the Manchester area. I've only just discovered your site, but strangely enough, I've just begun a similar project covering West Yorkshire. You might like to look at
http://members.tripod.com/~mbryant/wyindex.html
It's not very comprehensive at the moment, but Halifax, Holmfirth and Saltaire are being added in a couple of days, and I'm adding more every week or so. It'll be so much quicker when digital cameras become cheaper!

Martin.

Thanks for your comments. Good luck with your project. I'll include you in the "recommended " section of the New Eyewitness in Manchester, which will also include some photographs from other parts of northern England, so maybe we'll bump into each other!


Date: Wed, 6 Jan 1999 22:10:16 -0500
Subject: Website
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
From: Pat_Hough@sbe.scarborough.on.ca (Pat Hough)

Hi Aidan,
Happy New Year to you. I love reading all your news each week and I really enjoy your photo's. As you know, we are up to our eyeballs in snow over here and more is expected this weekend. We came to Toronto from Bolton thirty years ago. Any chance of you taking some photo's around the Bolton area? We try to visit England every couple of years but, unless the dollar improves, we will have to give it a miss this year. Ah well, I can always "visit" you each week.

Sorry, but so far I have only one picture of Bolton, the one on the right. I'll do some more, but getting round the area to photograph everyone's favourite place, and during good weather - it takes a long time! Can you mention any specific locations you'd like to see?


From: BonMurt@aol.com
Date: Wed, 6 Jan 1999 10:33:19 EST
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com

Subject: Snow in North America!
Whilst browsing through the Manchester on-line web site, I noticed that you had a feature on snow-storms in Chicago, USA. Well I have just moved over to Ottawa, Canada, in December 1998 and the weather here was just as bad as it was in Chicago. We had nearly three feet of snow and with temperatures as low as -35 degrees it can get pretty tough going, but unlike England where the road gritters come out after the worst has happened, here in Ottawa, they are out 24 hours a day and are always well prepared, maybe councils back home should do the same in order that the roads are cleared as somehow life seems to stop whenever England has a bit of snow and ice.
Yours Faithfully

S Yates Ex-pat, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.

Yes, a bit of snow like in the picture (right) of Manchester Central Mosque two years ago seems to cause major havoc. Currently rain and flooding are the problem, while in London, they've had the highest early Jan temperatures for 150 years. Have any EWM readers in North America taken any photos of the current snowy conditions? Please send some and I'll include them on this page.


From: Mank56@aol.com
Date: Tue, 5 Jan 1999 23:36:59 EST
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Mime-Version: 1.0
Subject: Winter storms in American Midwest
Sir:
I noted your reference to flights between Ringway and Chicago O'Hare being cancelled due to severe weather over here. I am an expatriate Mancunian, living in Michigan, about 2 hours east of Chicago. My parents have been visiting over Christmas and are due to fly out Wed. 6 Jan....weather permitting! Although the blizzard has blown through, we now have extreme low temperatures (zero degrees FAHRENHEIT) around noon on Jan 5. It's currently snowing again, and we're not sure whether my parents' connecting flight from here into Chicago is going to get out in time for them to make the AA flight to Manchester. At the moment, 40-odd degrees at their house in Chorlton looks positively tropical!

Best regards,

Nigel Bramwell, Kalamazoo, Michigan, USA.

Yes, at 11.30am Wednesday 6 Jan, it's 7.5 celsuis, 45 fahrenheit. If we could take some degrees off you guys and subtract from the temperature here, your parents could get their flight, and I could get some nice snow pictures around Manchester! I don't know how you manage to get through each winter in that part of the States. People complain about the weather here, but at least it's temperate. I'd like a bit of snow for a couple of weeks in the year, but I couldn't handle months of sub-zero temperatures.


Date: Wed, 6 Jan 1999 00:50:47 EST
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Eyewitness....

Dear Aidan...
I feel like I am getting to know you personally....I read your news each and every week....and just wanted to take a moment to let you know how much I enjoy and appreciate all the hard work you do with the pictures....

The year in review I also enjoyed very much.... I have a friend there...David P. Hadfield...and it is so nice to keep up with the news and able to discuss the local events with him.... I'm still looking for some pictures of Heald Green...maybe the "Beech Tree Pub", I know you will do in time....and I want to thank you in advance... I know many people read your Eyewitness each week....I just hope they take the time to let you know how much all your work is appreciated....

Sincerely,
Frann B. Southern
Paducah, Kentucky
January 5, 1999
e-mail.... fbsouth@apex.net

Didn't you see my picture of Heald Green (right)? I'll try and get the Beech Tree Pub next time I'm in that area, and the weather's good.

Yes, many people read, but not so many send me messages. Many website publishers don't even bother to reply to e-mail messages. I'm very happy to receive each one, and it only takes me a few minutes to paste them onto this page and write a reply, providing an opportunity for readers to have their say, moderated by me. It's interesting, readable content, and all I have to do is cut and paste!

So please e-mail me, Eyewitness readers. Who knows - through these pages, you might make contact with someone you didn't expect to make contact with!


From: "wazza" wazza@magna.com.au
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Date: Tue, 5 Jan 1999 16:26:25 +1100
MIME-Version: 1.0
Subject: Photographs
Priority: normal

Hi Aidan , here we are in 1999 the weather is warm and dry and life is worth living. Our Aussie cricketers have just wrapped up the Ashes series against the English team. I am you see a turn coat for now I support my adopted country. After 45 years I consider myself a full on Aussie. No I don't throw spears and boomerangs I am not that well assimilated .

My Mum is 90 years of age and asked if you had photographs of Davyhulme Hospital. In 1933/4 she spent some time in there and listened to music by "The Crystal Band" which had won some music awards. The hospital was new and impressive.

She also remembers bands playing in Victoria park Swinton in a purpose built bandstand . Have you a photo of the park ? I like the new format and it is interesting to read the messages from other ex Mancunians. It seems we cannot get the place out of our system ; it's addictive but I will decline rehabilitation.

Best Wishes
Arthur Hanlon

Davyhulme Hospital is now, I think, Trafford General Hospital. It went down in history as the hospital where the NHS started in 1948. There were commemorations there in 1998. I'll see if I can get over to those places when the weather improves.

Date: Tue, 5 Jan 1999 09:21:13 -0600 (CST)
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
From: COOPET@webtv.net (TODD COOPER)
Subject: Snow Affecting Manchester

I am a long time reader who lives in southern Missouri about 400 miles southwest of Chicago and the weather here (and all over the Midwest) has been awful. In addition to the snow and ice, temperatures have been from 0 to 12 degrees since the first of the year with wind chills in the minus (!) teens and twentys.

Really enjoy your page. I first stumbled upon it while trying to learn more about the Manchester area as my wife has friends that live in Whitefield (right). We are planning a trip later in the year to see it in person.

Thanks for doing such a great job.

Thanks for your message and the kind comments.Here the weather is cloudy and mild. I wouldn't mind experiencing your weather for a week or so, and I could take some photos, but it must be difficult to live through a whole winter of it. People complain about our "coastal" weather patterns, but it's more varied and less extreme than your "continental" climate. Hope you enjoy Manchester when you come.


Date: Tue, 5 Jan 1999 06:32:00 -0000
Lawrence J. Murphy slm8@worldnet.att.net

Thanks for the memories - great to be able to sit at my computer at 6 a.m. in New Jersey, fifty miles from New York, and stroll down memory lane with your web site.

Keep up the good work I really enjoyed it. Sue Murphy formerly of Fallowfield, Manchester 14

Glad you like it, and hope to bring you even more up-to-date images, as well as very old ones, soon. The one on the right is Platt Fields Park, Fallowfield.


Date: Sun, 03 Jan 1999 09:25:59 -0500
From: rtaylor rtaylor@dreamscape.com
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: thanks


Just a line to thank you for your words and photos. I was born in Middleton in 1957 . came to the states as a teenager. you are anexcellent photographer with a great eye. Your photographs tug on my heart. I thought the place I knew didnt exist anymore, I was surprised to see much has remained the same. thanks for the memories. (sounds like a song title):-) thank you.

Robert Taylor Liverpool New York USA

Has anyone written a song "I left my heart in Ma-a-nchester"? Doesn't sound quite right , but a lot of people do miss Manchester whether people from here who've emigrated, or visitors who've gone back home. I spent some time in New York summer 81, I thought I'd "come home". Took quite a few photos there too. In some ways, I think Manchester is like a "little" New York. Anyhow, thanks for the good wishes and please keep reading! Oh, there's a song called "Manchester Morning" by Jonathan Young - see EWM Recommends, coming later this month.


From: "chris morris" chris@mozza23.freeserve.co.uk
To: aidan@anamaria.u-net.com
Subject: Arndale Bus Station
Date: Fri, 1 Jan 1999 02:41:49 -0000

Hey could you please tell me what the old Arndale bus station will be transformed into as no-one has mentioned its future use and do you think that this once-excellent terminus should be re-furbished and re-opened.thanks

Chris

As far as I am aware, the old Arndale bus station will not be re-opened. There are plans for a new bus and Metrolink interchange on the empty site next to Shude Hill, see photo right. There were problems with the Arndale bus station right from the start - the height was found to be too low and had to be increased, then I believe there were ventilation problems, so I'm not sure if re-opening it is the best option. Perhaps this new terminus will be better, but I'll wait to see what it looks like before I comment!

 

<<PREVIOUS | EWM HOME PAGE

Click here to subscribe to the Eyewitness In Manchester Newsletter
provided by ManchesterOnline